Home > Videos

👶🏆🧠✨ What kids know about motivation (and we don’t) | Betsy Blackard | TEDxClaremontGraduateUniversity

🤖 AI Summary

• 💡 The best way to motivate a child is to simply let them do whatever they feel like doing [00:10].
• 🏃 Children’s motivation works like a running leap: the bigger the challenge, the further they need to back up to ensure their leap is a success [02:19].
• 🔙 A child appearing to back away from a big challenge, like a large water slide, is actually backing up by mastering a smaller challenge, such as a baby slide, to build confidence [03:02].
• 🛑 Caregivers attempting to constantly be the child’s motivation is an exhausting and massive burden [04:16].
• ✅ When a child backs away, look for signs they are backing up to take a running lead; trust their process so you can let go and stay curious [04:51] [05:05].
• 🧠 Kids are programmed to succeed with an inborn strategy like the running leap; adults only need to stay out of their way [05:36].
• 🧘 Forcing a child to take a leap they do not feel ready for backfires, resulting in resentful obedience or feelings of incompetence and laziness [10:31].
• 📈 Disrupting the backing up process increases the perceived difficulty of the challenge, forcing the child to take more backward steps [10:55].
• ✨ Help children recognize they are using the running leap by acknowledging their process, which transforms self-doubt into self-trust and provides a tool for future challenges [06:36] [11:07].
• 🤔 Ask yourself: what are they doing, and how is it already working for them, instead of trying to push or plead [14:06].

🤔 Evaluation

• 🔄 The video’s concept of the running leap—where children instinctively seek confidence-building steps before tackling a large task—aligns closely with established psychological frameworks focused on intrinsic motivation.
• 🛡️ The message to step back and trust the child’s process echoes the principles of Self-Determination Theory by Deci and Ryan, which posits that humans require satisfaction of three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness.
  • 🎓 When children feel autonomy (control over choices) and competence (feeling effective), their intrinsic motivation flourishes.
  • 🛑 Forcing a child to perform (pushing them to jump when they are not ready) thwarts their autonomy and competence, leading to controlled motivation rather than autonomous motivation, which is detrimental to long-term well-being, according to Self-Determination Theory (The Exchange and selfdeterminationtheory.org).
• ⚖️ The speaker’s recommended approach of being responsive while letting the child lead their challenge is highly consistent with Authoritative Parenting research.
  • 👪 Authoritative parents set clear expectations while providing warmth, support, and respecting the child’s need for independence and problem-solving, which consistently correlates with the most positive developmental outcomes for children, including higher self-esteem and self-regulation (StatPearls and Murray State’s Digital Commons).
  • ❌ This contrasts sharply with the controlling, pressuring style (Authoritarian) the speaker advises against, which is linked to lower self-esteem and difficulty in decision-making (StatPearls).
• ❓ Topics to explore for a better understanding include:
  • Optimal Challenge: How to determine the precise point where a task is challenging enough to build competence but not overwhelming enough to cause the child to back up entirely, a balance referenced in the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University research on motivation.
  • Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Goals: How children balance the desire for intrinsic rewards (like the fun of sliding down the baby slide) versus extrinsic rewards (like the social win of going down the big slide or the reward of finishing math homework to go play).

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

❓ Q: What is the running leap in child motivation?

✨ A: The running leap is a behavioral strategy where a child instinctively takes backward steps, such as seeking out a smaller, simpler task, to build the necessary confidence and skills before attempting a difficult or overwhelming challenge [02:19].

❓ Q: How should a parent react when a child avoids a challenging task?

✅ A: Instead of forcing compliance, observe the child to understand how they are attempting to back up or bolster their confidence; trust that they possess the inner motivation to return to the challenge once they feel ready and self-assured [04:51].

❓ Q: Why is it harmful to pressure a child to face a fear immediately?

🛑 A: Pressuring a child to take a leap before they feel ready undermines their sense of self-trust and competence, which can lead to negative emotional outcomes like resentment, incompetence, or anxiety, making future challenges feel even more daunting [10:31].

❓ Q: How can an adult help a child build self-trust?

🗣️ A: Adults can help by acknowledging the child’s process and strategy, using language that highlights how the child figured out what they needed to do to succeed, which reinforces their self-trust for future problem-solving [12:05].

📚 Book Recommendations

↔️ Similar

• 👨‍🚀 The Self-Driven Child: The 🔬 Science and 🤔 Sense of Giving Your Kids More 🕹️ Control Over Their Lives by William Stixrud and Ned Johnson
  • 📖 This book explores how fostering a child’s autonomy is the best antidote to stress and the key to developing intrinsic motivation and resilience.
• 🐬 The Self-Motivated Kid by Dr. Shimi Kang
  • 💡 Drawing on neuroscience, this book advocates for a Dolphin Parent model, which guides children with compassion and authority while focusing on balance, play, and exploration to nurture internal drive.
• 🏎️⛽ Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us by Daniel H. Pink
  • 📚 Pink details the science of intrinsic motivation—mastery, autonomy, and purpose—which is the same internal drive the speaker suggests children naturally possess.

🆚 Contrasting

• 🐅 Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother by Amy Chua
  • ⚖️ This book advocates for strict, high-pressure parenting focused on academic achievement and extrinsic measures of success, offering a stark contrast to the video’s emphasis on non-interference and intrinsic motivation.
• 🤯 Unconditional Parenting Moving from Rewards and Punishments to Love and Reason by Alfie Kohn
  • 🗣️ While similar in valuing autonomy, Kohn’s work is contrasting in its specific attack on all forms of extrinsic control, including praise and rewards, whereas the video implicitly allows for goal-oriented motivation (finishing math to go play) when driven by the child’s end goal.
• 🚦 Setting Limits with Your Child by Robert J. MacKenzie
  • 📏 This resource focuses heavily on parental control, discipline, and establishing clear boundaries to manage behavior, which presents a practical, more structured, and less do nothing alternative to the approach presented.

🎨 Creatively Related

• 🌊🧘🏼‍♀️🧠📈 Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience by Mihály Csíkszentmihályi
  • 💡 This book describes the mental state of flow, achieved when a challenge perfectly matches one’s skill level. The running leap is the child actively managing their environment to enter this optimal state of challenge and competence.
• 🌱🧘🏼‍♀️🏆 Mindset: The New Psychology of Success by Carol S. Dweck
  • 🧠 Dweck’s work on fixed versus growth mindsets relates to the video’s core idea: by focusing on the process and effort (backing up) rather than the outcome (making the jump), adults help children adopt a growth mindset essential for embracing challenges.
• 🗺️ Free to Learn Why Unleashing the Instinct to Play Will Make Our Children Happier, More Self-Reliant, and Better Students for Life by Peter Gray
  • 🏞️ This book argues that children are inherently educational and designed to learn through self-directed play, which is the foundational belief supporting the speaker’s advice to trust the child’s inner process and stay out of their way.