Home > Books

📈📉 Progress and Poverty

🛒 Progress and Poverty. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

💰💡🌍 Poverty persists amidst technological advancement and increasing wealth because private land ownership allows landowners to capture unearned economic rent, primarily through a proposed single tax on land values to fund public services.

🤖 AI Summary

📉 Core Problem: Poverty Amidst Progress

• ❓ The Paradox: Increasing societal wealth and technological advancement paradoxically correlate with persistent or worsening poverty and economic inequality.
• 🌱 Root Cause: Private ownership of land allows landowners to extract economic rent – value created by community growth and public investment, not individual effort.
• 📈 Economic Rent Defined: Payment to a factor of production (e.g., land) in excess of costs needed to bring it into production, often unearned income derived from scarcity or positional advantage. This unearned increment is captured by landowners as rent, rather than benefitting labor or capital.

🛠️ Proposed Solution: The Single Tax

• ⚙️ Mechanism: Abolish all other taxes (on labor, capital, production) and institute a single, high tax on the unimproved value of land (Land Value Tax, LVT).
• 🤔 Rationale:
  • ⚖️ Justice: Land value is created by the community; therefore, its value should be collected by the community for public good.
  • ⏱️ Efficiency: LVT does not distort economic decision-making or create deadweight loss, as the supply of land is fixed. It incentivizes productive land use.
  • 🤝 Equity: LVT is progressive, paid by owners of valuable land, and cannot be shifted to tenants or workers.

🔑 Key Concepts & Critiques Explored

• 🏭 Factors of Production: Land, labor, capital. George emphasizes wealth as product of labor applied to land.
• 🙅‍♀️ Iron Law of Wages & Malthusianism: George refutes these theories, arguing that wages are not drawn from capital, but produced by labor, and that population growth doesn’t inherently lead to poverty.
• 🏘️ Land Speculation: Identified as a major driver of recessions and poverty, diverting wealth to rent instead of wages.

⚖️ Evaluation

• 📜 Historical Impact & Influence: Progress and Poverty was a bestseller, influencing the Progressive Era and inspiring figures like Leo Tolstoy and Mohandas Gandhi. John Dewey estimated it had wider distribution than almost all other books on political economy combined at the time.
• 👍 Moral and Efficiency Arguments: Classical economists, even before George, recognized the theoretical perfection of LVT due to its strong moral basis (community-created value) and lack of economic distortion.
• 👎 Critiques of Capital and Interest: Karl Marx and Silvio Gesell criticized George’s theories on capital and interest, with Gesell proposing land nationalization over taxation and attributing interest to liquidity preference, not just land issues. Marxists also argue Georgism overlooks means of production ownership as root causes of inequality.
• 📊 Tax Incidence and Progressivity: A Land Value Tax is generally considered progressive, primarily falling on wealthy landowners and not easily shifted to tenants or consumers. However, some scholars question its impact on overall tax system progressivity if replacing other taxes like federal income tax.
• 🚧 Practical Implementation Challenges: Despite theoretical advantages, real-world implementations of LVT have been relatively few, limiting empirical data for research. Valuation challenges, political viability concerns, and potential backlash from those facing higher taxes are noted hurdles.

🔍 Topics for Further Understanding

• 🏙️ Modern applications of Georgist principles in urban planning and housing policy.
• 🗺️ Comparative analysis of LVT implementation in various global jurisdictions.
• 💻 The role of intellectual property and digital monopolies as forms of economic rent in the 21st century.
• 📈 Economic models simulating the impact of LVT on income distribution and economic growth.
• 🧠 Psychological and sociological barriers to implementing radical economic reforms like the single tax.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

💡 Q: What is the main argument of Progress and Poverty?

✅ A: Progress and Poverty argues that the primary cause of poverty and economic inequality amidst societal progress is the private appropriation of economic rent from land, and proposes a single tax on land values as the remedy.

💡 Q: Who was Henry George?

✅ A: Henry George was an American economist and social theorist, best known for his advocacy of the single tax on land value, which he elaborated in his influential 1879 book, Progress and Poverty.

💡 Q: What is economic rent according to Henry George?

✅ A: According to Henry George, economic rent refers to the unearned income derived from the ownership of land, whose value increases due to community growth, public investment, and natural advantages, rather than the landowner’s labor or improvements.

💡 Q: What is a Land Value Tax (LVT)?

✅ A: A Land Value Tax (LVT) is a tax levied on the unimproved value of land, excluding any buildings or improvements. Henry George advocated it as a single tax to replace all other taxes, aiming to capture socially created land value for public benefit.

💡 Q: Is Progress and Poverty still relevant today?

✅ A: Many of the insights in Progress and Poverty, particularly regarding income inequality, housing affordability, and the nature of unearned wealth, remain highly relevant in the 21st century, with renewed interest in Georgist ideas globally.

📚 Book Recommendations

📚 Similar

• 📖 Agrarian Justice by Thomas Paine
• 📖 Owning the Earth: The Transformative History of Land Ownership by Andro Linklater
• 📖 The Rent of the Earth by David Ricardo

🔄 Contrasting

• 📖 Das Kapital by Karl Marx
• 📖 The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith
• 📖 The Natural Economic Order through Free Land and Free Money by Silvio Gesell

🔗 Related

• 🏛️💰 Debt: The First 5,000 Years by David Graeber
• 📖 Rentier Capitalism by Brett Christophers
• 🏚️💰 Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City by Matthew Desmond

🫵 What Do You Think?

🤔 Considering the ongoing debates about wealth inequality and housing crises, do you believe Henry George’s proposal for a single tax on land value offers a viable solution for contemporary societies, or are there fundamental challenges that prevent its widespread adoption?