Home > Videos

🤫💰🪙 This Is What They Don’t Tell You About Money And Gold | Prof. L. Randall Wray

🤖 AI Summary

• 🪙 Gold prices are not a reliable inflation hedge; for example, gold only returned to its 1980 inflation-adjusted peak value by the modern day [00:28].
• 📈 Stocks like the Dow have historically performed much better than gold, beating inflation by a significant margin over the long run [03:45].
• 🏛️ The Gold Standard did not guarantee price stability, as prices were highly volatile between 1800 and 1900, surging during wars and collapsing in depressions [04:46].
• 💎 Gold is a real asset with utility (e.g., jewelry), but it cannot be considered a monetary asset because it is not someone’s debt [05:22].
• 💲 Money must serve as a measuring unit (money of account) and represent someone’s outstanding debt to be classified as money [13:00].
• ₿ Bitcoin is a speculative non-monetary asset due to extreme volatility and the fact that it represents nobody’s debt, hindering its transactional use [18:21].
• 🛑 Central banks cannot control the money supply; they primarily manage interest rates and swap financial assets, such as exchanging government bonds for reserves [23:19].
• 🏦 Quantitative Easing only changes the composition of bank portfolios, swapping assets for reserves that cannot circulate into the real economy [26:27].
• 💸 New money enters the economy solely through treasury spending (fiscal policy), which directly increases private bank deposits [27:40].
• 🔄 Governments typically do not repay national debt; they consistently roll it over into new securities, as the US debt history shows a steady increase since 1789 [32:17].
• 💵 The US federal government, as the currency issuer, always possesses the capacity to pay interest and service its dollar-denominated debt using keystrokes [38:25].
• ⚖️ High interest payments on government debt exacerbate inequality by transferring income to top wealth holders and risk worsening inflation or exchange rate stability [39:30].
• 🛡️ Interference in the global payment system, like freezing foreign assets, undermines confidence in the US dollar, pushing nations toward alternative reserve currencies [46:18].

🤔 Evaluation

• 🧐 The video presents Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) which says that a sovereign currency issuer (like the US) is financially unconstrained and faces inflation as its only limit.
• 🧠 Topics for further exploration include the historical application of functional finance (a precursor to MMT), the precise mechanics of the job guarantee program advocated by MMT economists like Pavlina R. Tcherneva, and the open-economy implications of MMT for countries without reserve currency status.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

📈 Q: Is gold a reliable long-term investment for hedging against inflation?

💰 A: Gold is not a reliable long-term inflation hedge; historical data shows that inflation-adjusted gold prices may take decades merely to recover previous peaks, making assets like stocks historically superior [03:45].

🏦 Q: How does a sovereign government, like the United States, actually create new money?

✍️ A: A sovereign government creates new money not through central bank actions like Quantitative Easing, but through treasury spending (fiscal policy), where the government pays for goods or services by crediting private bank accounts with dollars created via keystrokes [27:40].

💸 Q: Why is government debt, denominated in its own currency, not considered a conventional burden?

🛡️ A: Government debt is not a conventional burden because the currency issuer can always afford to service the debt and pay interest, as it can keystroke the necessary dollars into existence; the constraint is not financial capacity, but the risk of inflation if spending exceeds the economy’s real resource capacity [38:25].

📚 Book Recommendations

↔️ Similar

• 💰📉➡️📈🗳️ The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People’s Economy by Stephanie Kelton.
  • 💡 This book provides a popular and accessible explanation of MMT’s core principles, arguing that deficits are not inherently harmful.
• 💰🏛️ Modern Money Theory: A Primer on Macroeconomics for Sovereign Monetary Systems by L. Randall Wray.
  • 🔑 A comprehensive academic text directly from the speaker, detailing the MMT framework for sovereign monetary systems.

🆚 Contrasting

• 📉 The Trouble With Macroeconomics by Paul Romer.
  • ✏️ Romer, a Nobel laureate, criticizes the state of macroeconomics, offering a counterpoint to the MMT school’s foundational assumptions about economic models.
• 🏦 A Monetary and Fiscal History of the United States, 1961–2021 by Alan S. Blinder.
  • 🏛️ This offers a detailed, conventional analysis of US monetary and fiscal policy, providing an orthodox perspective on the debt, the Fed’s role, and policy outcomes.

🎨 Creatively Related

• 🏛️💰 Debt: The First 5,000 Years by David Graeber.
  • 🌍 An anthropological history that explores how money originated as debt and social obligation, reinforcing the MMT concept of money as a debt relation.
• 🚀🌍💰 Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism by Mariana Mazzucato.
  • 🚀 This book argues for a proactive, mission-oriented role for the state in economic life, aligning with MMT’s emphasis on using fiscal policy to achieve public purpose.