Home > Videos

🚨🚓📺🎤 Police Chases: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

🤖 AI Summary

✨ Police chases are gravely dangerous, a fact often obscured by their portrayal as action-movie staples [00:04].

• 💀 Over a six-year period, more than 3,300 people died in pursuits across the US, an average of nearly two per day [01:40].

• ⚰️ Most fatalities are not the fleeing driver; over 500 victims were innocent bystanders [01:53].

• 🚗 Chases are the most dangerous of all ordinary police activities, similar to firing a 4,000lb bullet down the street [02:00].

• 🚨 Roughly 90% of pursuits start for low-stakes infractions, such as traffic violations, non-violent crimes, or no crime at all [03:00], [04:10].

• 🗺️ There are no mandated national standards, leading nearly 18,000 agencies to have widely varying, often permissive, chase policies [07:40].

• ⚠️ The Precision Immobilization Technique (PIT) maneuver is incredibly dangerous, especially at high speeds, and can cause vehicles to roll over [09:26].

• 🛑 Since 2017, the PIT maneuver has killed at least 87 people, including passengers and bystanders [10:29].

• 👥 Black people are disproportionately harmed, accounting for over a third of pursuit fatalities and over a quarter of bystander fatalities [12:31].

• 🚫 Restricting chases to violent felonies is not associated with an increase in fleeing suspects or higher crime rates [14:18].

• 📸 Police have safer alternatives for minor offenses, like using camera networks and license plate readers to apprehend suspects later via investigators [15:09].

• 🏛️ Legal protections like qualified immunity and restrictive state laws make it difficult to hold officers and agencies liable for pursuit-related injuries [20:48].

• ✅ National standards must be adopted, restricting pursuits to violent crimes where the suspect poses an imminent threat to commit another [22:28].

🤔 Evaluation

📰 The claims regarding pursuit fatalities and causes are supported by external data. The San Francisco Chronicle’s investigation, titled First-of-its-kind database: Majority of people killed in police chases aren’t the fleeing drivers, confirms 3,336 deaths from 2017 to 2022. The report also corroborates the video’s core argument that most fatal chases originate from minor infractions, citing that 82% of reviewed fatal cases started from traffic stops or suspected nonviolent crimes.

⚖️ Highly reliable, unbiased sources confirm the policy landscape. A Police Executive Research Forum (PERF) report on vehicular pursuit guidelines supports the need for national standards and the restriction of chases to violent crimes posing an imminent threat. PERF also notes that there is no evidence linking restrictive pursuit policies to increased car thefts, directly challenging the “myth” mentioned in the video. The National Survey of Vehicle Pursuit Policies, published by SF.gov, highlights the wide variation in policies and the fact that 25% of LAPD vehicle pursuits from 2018 to 2023 ended in collisions, mainly impacting third-party victims.

🔭 Topics to explore for a better understanding:

• 🛰️ The efficacy of non-contact tools, such as GPS tracking darts or comprehensive air support, as alternatives to the PIT maneuver, since the SF.gov report notes air support greatly increases apprehension rates.

• 🧠 De-escalation training and policy development focused on the psychological factors that drive an officer’s decision to continue or intensify a pursuit when the risks clearly outweigh the benefits.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

❓ Q: Why are police vehicle pursuits so dangerous to the public?

🛑 A: Police pursuits are the most dangerous of routine police activities because the speed and unpredictable driving of both the suspect and the officer often lead to catastrophic collisions. The result is an average of nearly two fatalities every day, with most victims being innocent bystanders or passengers in the fleeing vehicle.

❓ Q: Do strict laws limiting police chases cause crime rates to rise?

📈 A: No, research indicates that the argument that restricting chases increases crime is a myth. Jurisdictions that implement restrictive pursuit policies, such as limiting chases to violent felonies only, do not experience a significant increase in the number of suspects who flee or in their overall crime rates.

❓ Q: What types of crimes typically trigger a fatal police chase?

📉 A: The majority of fatal police chases are initiated for non-violent, minor offenses. Over 80% of these deadly incidents start with basic traffic violations, such as a broken tail light or a seat belt infraction, or suspected non-violent property crimes.

❓ Q: What legal doctrines prevent holding police accountable for pursuit injuries?

🏛️ A: Legal accountability is severely limited by doctrines such as qualified immunity, which shields officers from liability. Furthermore, in many states, laws require that a police car physically hit the victim for the agency to bear liability, making it nearly impossible for innocent bystanders hit by the suspect’s car to successfully sue the department.

📚 Book Recommendations

↔️ Similar

• 🛑👮 The End of Policing by Alex Vitale

  • 📖 This book proposes policy alternatives to police intervention for social problems, advocating for non-carceral and non-aggressive responses, similar to the video’s call to restrict chases.

• Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America’s Police Forces by Radley Balko

  • ⚔️ It details the increasing militarization of American police, which informs the culture that accepts high-risk, aggressive tactics like the PIT maneuver used during pursuits.

🆚 Contrasting

• The War on Cops: How the New Attack on Law and Order Makes Everyone Less Safe by Heather Mac Donald

  • 👮 This work argues that increased scrutiny and restrictions on police, including policies that limit pursuits, embolden criminals and contribute to rising violent crime rates.

• A Call for Recompense: The Need for Proactive Law Enforcement and Victim Services by James C. Smith (Example of a supportive source)

  • 🛡️ This text focuses on the necessity of immediate, aggressive law enforcement response to establish authority and ensure public safety by rapidly apprehending suspects, contrasting with the video’s policy of termination.

🎨 Creatively Related

• Media Spectacle by Douglas Kellner

  • 📺 The book offers an analysis of how major events, like the O.J. Simpson chase, become cultural spectacles that shape public understanding and consumption of crime, race, and justice.

• 🤔🐇🐢 Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman

  • 🧠 This book explains the psychology of rapid decision-making, providing a framework for analyzing the high-stakes, System 1 choices officers make during a high-speed pursuit versus the calculated, rational policy decisions.