bagrounds.org

7 min read

Home > Videos

👥🌍📢💡 How Common Knowledge Shapes the World | Steven Pinker | TED

🔦 Highlights

  1. 🚫 Why are autocrats terrified of public protests? The reason was explained by Gandhi when he said, “100,000 Englishmen cannot control 350 million Indians if the Indians refuse to cooperate”.
  2. ✊ This common knowledge allows them to coordinate their resistance whether by literally storming the palace or by bringing the apparatus of the state to a halt through boycotts and work stoppages.
  3. 🤝 Basic civility depends on norms such as that you don’t brazenly lie, you don’t insult people to their faces, you don’t prosecute personal vendettas.
  4. 🌐 In the global arena, peace depends on norms such as that nation states are immortal, national borders are grandfathered in, conquest is unacceptable, and nuclear weapons are unthinkable.
  5. 📉 I hope that, having explained the logic behind human harmony, I don’t have to explain how these norms are currently under threat or what is at stake if we lose them.

🤖 AI Summary

  • 💡 Common knowledge is logically distinct from private knowledge [00:36]. Private knowledge is I know something and you know it, while common knowledge includes the infinite recursion of I know that you know that I know that you know it, ad infinitum [00:46].
  • 🤝 Common knowledge is essential for coordination [00:58]. Without it, individuals are whipsawed by anticipating the anticipation of others, preventing agreement on a focal point or course of action [01:46].
  • 🗣️ Direct speech, public or conspicuous salience, or a convention resolves coordination dilemmas by creating a shared public fact or implicit agreement [02:25].
  • 💰 Coordination at large scales drives legal and financial agreements, such as driving rules and the acceptance of money [03:42].
  • 🚫 Autocrats fear public protests because common knowledge allows the populace to coordinate their collective resistance, whether by storming the palace or through boycotts and work stoppages [04:30].
  • 📉 Speculative investing, similar to Keynes’s beauty contest, relies on cycles of recursive mentalizing where assets are purchased based on the hope of unloading them on future investors—the “greater fools” [06:01].
  • 💥 Bubbles pop when the doubt itself becomes common knowledge, leading investors to run for the exits out of fear that everyone else is selling, resulting in a bank run or great depression [07:20].
  • 💖 Social relationships are coordination games that are cemented by common knowledge generating signals like eye contact, blushing, and laughter [08:35].
  • 🤫 Innuendo and euphemism veil intentions to allow for the deniability of common knowledge, which permits the maintenance of a fictional relationship, such as a platonic friendship [10:41].
  • 📜 Norms are ways of living together that exist because everyone knows they exist, underpinning basic civility and international peace, and are vulnerable to imploding if overtly flouted [12:30].

🤔 Evaluation

  • 📚 The principles discussed—particularly the use of focal points for coordination—are grounded in the work of Nobel laureate Thomas Schelling’s The Strategy of Conflict [Source: Princeton University Press], a highly reliable source in game theory [02:50].
  • 🔄 The video extensively covers how common knowledge facilitates social coordination and collective action [04:50].
  • 🚫 A contrasting concept to explore is pluralistic ignorance, where individuals privately reject a norm but falsely assume that everyone else supports it [Source: Psychology Today by the American Psychological Association]. This failure of common knowledge causes a group to adhere to a norm that virtually no one actually believes [Source: The Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by Gilbert, Fiske, and Lindzey].
  • 🔍 Further exploration is warranted into how modern digital media and echo chambers rapidly establish or disrupt common knowledge across large populations, especially concerning political polarization.
  • 📈 Investigating the history of financial bubbles—like the Dutch Tulip Mania—using the lens of Keynes’s beauty contest would provide a deeper understanding of recursive mentalizing in markets [06:01].

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: 🧐 What is the core difference between private knowledge and common knowledge?

A: 🤯 Private knowledge is when two people simply know the same fact [00:36]. Common knowledge, however, is an infinitely recursive state where everyone knows the fact, and everyone knows that everyone else knows the fact, ad infinitum [00:46]. This shared awareness of shared knowledge is what enables group coordination [00:58].

Q: 🗣️ How does common knowledge solve coordination problems like the separated couple in Manhattan?

A: 🗺️ Coordination requires a focal point or a public agreement [02:42]. The separated couple example highlights how, without a public signal, they are trapped in a futile cycle of anticipating the other’s anticipations [01:32]. A focal point—a conspicuously salient place like the big clock in Grand Central Station—allows both to simultaneously anticipate that the other will select it, creating the necessary common knowledge for them to meet [02:50].

Q: 🤫 Why do people use innuendo and euphemism, like “Netflix and chill,” instead of direct speech?

A: 🎭 Innuendo is used to avoid establishing the common knowledge that a specific overture was made or an intention was revealed [10:41]. If direct speech is used, common knowledge is established that the relationship has changed and the overture can’t be taken back [11:34]. Veiled language allows individuals to maintain the fiction of the prior, platonic relationship [11:15].

Q: 📈 What is the role of common knowledge in speculative financial bubbles?

A: 💰 Financial speculation, according to Keynes, is a game of recursive mentalizing—choosing the asset that one anticipates the greatest number of other investors will choose [06:01]. Common knowledge acts to levitate an asset’s price based on the shared expectation of rising value, not its inherent productive worth [07:12]. Bubbles pop when the doubt about the asset’s value becomes common knowledge, triggering a mass panic sale [07:28].

📚 Book Recommendations

Similar

  • ⚔️♟️ The Strategy of Conflict by Thomas Schelling [Source: Princeton University Press]. This book introduces the concept of the focal point, which is central to the video’s explanation of how unspoken common knowledge facilitates coordination problems.
  • 🗣️ The Language Instinct by Steven Pinker [Source: William Morrow and Company]. This work explores the nature of language as an innate human ability, touching upon how direct speech evolved and functions as a powerful, public mechanism for generating common knowledge.
  • 🎲 Game Theory: A Nontechnical Introduction by Morten D. Davis [Source: Dover Publications]. Provides a highly accessible overview of the mathematical principles, including coordination games, that underpin the logic of common assumptions in social interaction.

Contrasting

  • 💸 Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds by Charles Mackay [Source: Richard Bentley]. This classic text details historical failures of collective common belief, such as the Tulip Mania, illustrating the dangers that arise when recursive mentalizing detaches from objective reality.
  • 🤔🐇🐢 Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman [Source: Farrar, Straus and Giroux]. Explores the systemic cognitive biases (System 1 vs. System 2) that can override the logical decision-making framework implied by the common knowledge model, often leading to collective irrationality.
  • 🐘 Why We Are So Cranky by Elisha C. Pool and Robert B. Cialdini [Source: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology]. This work discusses the backfiring of descriptive norms, which is a related concept that contrasts with the video’s focus on successful coordination by highlighting how the awareness of what most people do can be a detriment to social behavior.
  • ♟️🧠📈🎯 The Art of Strategy: A Game Theorist’s Guide to Success in Business and Life by Avinash K. Dixit and Barry J. Nalebuff [Source: W. W. Norton & Company]. This book offers a practical, modern application of the game theory concepts—including coordination and threats—discussed in the context of the video’s examples of veiled language.
  • 🌍 Albion’s Seed: Four British Folkways in America by David Hackett Fischer [Source: Oxford University Press]. This historical work demonstrates how distinct founding cultures established durable, unspoken social conventions and norms that continue to shape regional differences in the United States.
  • 🖼️ The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life by Erving Goffman [Source: Anchor Books]. Examines social interaction through the lens of theatrical performance, which is directly relevant to the video’s discussion of role-playing and the need to maintain polite fictions to avoid polluting the pool of common assumptions.

🐦 Tweet

Graph View

Backlinks