bagrounds.org

4 min read

Home > Videos

👨‍⚖️⬆️🏛️ Brooks and Capehart on the Comey indictment and upending of DOJ norms

🤖 AI Summary

  • ⚖️ The charges against former FBI Director James Comey are an erosion of our democracy, a blatant violation of fundamental principles [00:29].
  • ❓ The Justice Department’s primary questions—did a person commit a crime and can it be proved—have been supplanted by: does the president want me to do this [00:35].
  • 📝 The indictment itself is flimsy, having been done a week before the term runs out by prosecutors who had never prosecuted anything before [01:04].
  • ⚖️ Justice is supposed to be blind, meted out without fear or favor of the powerful and certainly without pressure from the president [01:31].
  • 🏛️ The system relied on norms and presidents restraining themselves, and the eruption of these norms has destroyed the system [03:15].
  • 🇺🇸 The independence of the Department of Justice is gone, leading to compromised America’s credibility abroad, where the rule of law has long been the cornerstone of democracy [02:53], [04:40].
  • 🚨 Leaders of good character are necessary, as a person lacking it would single out enemies for prosecution without evidence [05:16].
  • 🔥 Regarding the government shutdown, it was entirely predictable that the administration would try to take a “flamethrower” to the federal government [06:24].
  • ⚠️ Chuck Schumer’s decision to head toward a shutdown will hand the administration incredible latitude to fire people, decimate agencies, and pour money where they need it for political support [06:40].
  • ❌ The shutdown is not the battle to fight because it will just lead to the destruction of the federal government, and there is no upside for the Democrats [07:28].
  • ⚔️ Democrats have to play hardball with the administration, meeting their hardball tactics with their own [08:03].
  • 🛡️ Democrats are wisely demanding safeguards for health care for 15 million people and that Congress dial back the president’s rescission power [08:32].

🤔 Evaluation

  • 🤝 The discussion provides a strong contrast in political strategy regarding the government shutdown while maintaining unanimity on the erosion of the Department of Justice’s independence.
  • 📜 Brooks argues from a normative and institutional perspective, cautioning that a shutdown hands immense, destructive power to the current administration, making it an imprudent political fight [06:40], [07:28].
  • 🔥 Capehart argues from an ethical and combative perspective, asserting that the administration’s goal is to destroy the federal government regardless of a shutdown, so Democrats must fight now to safeguard programs like health care and limit executive power [08:15], [08:42].
  • ⚖️ The analysis largely focuses on the political implications of the Comey indictment (erosion of norms, threat to democracy) and less on the specific legal arguments of the two-page charge.
  • 🧠 Topics to explore for a better understanding:
    • 🔎 The historical precedents for presidential interference in the Department of Justice beyond the cited example of John F. Kennedy appointing his brother [02:53].
    • 📉 The practical, on-the-ground consequences of a shutdown on specific federal agencies and the 15 million citizens whose healthcare subsidies are at risk [07:15], [08:32].
    • ✍️ A deeper dive into the legal standard required to indict an individual like Comey for unauthorized disclosure or obstruction.

📚 Book Recommendations

  • 🗳️🏛️☠️ How Democracies Die by Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt: The book details how institutional norms erode and how leaders undermine democratic institutions, which directly relates to the conversation about the DOJ’s independence.
  • 🔥 The System: Who Rigged It, How to Fix It by Robert B. Reich: This offers a perspective on how power and political hardball tactics, such as the shutdown fight, are used to benefit certain interests over the public good.
  • ⬆️🤥🏛️ A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership by James Comey: Recommended as a contrasting or supplementary read to understand the former FBI Director’s perspective and defense against the actions discussed in the video.
  • 🇺🇸 The Looming Crisis in American Democracy: A Toolkit for Our Political Future by Suzanne Mettler: Provides ideas for institutional reform that address the failure of norms Brooks lamented, suggesting concrete legal changes [03:08].

🐦 Tweet

Graph View

Backlinks