bagrounds.org

9 min read

Home > Videos

🇺🇸🗣️👂 American Conversations: Diana Butler Bass

🤖 AI Summary

  • 🕰️ Time should be understood cyclically, not linearly. Western culture uses linear stories with beginnings, middles, and ends, featuring heroes and villains that conclude with a winner [03:08]. 🔄 The Christian year, however, is a spiritual tool structured as a spiral or circle, helping people experience God’s story through time [04:06].
  • ✝️ The Christian year’s climax is in the middle. The first part, starting with Advent, moves toward the center, which is Easter Sunday, the most important event [04:24]. 💥 The resurrection is an explosion of love that then presses outward in the second half of the year to include all who seek to live by the love of God and neighbor [05:07].
  • 👑 Early Christianity was a no-kings movement. Jesus’ Jewish story was based on a seasonal, cyclical sense of time centered on shalom (peace) and Sabbath, dreaming of a world with an economy of rest and fulfillment [07:14]. 🏛️ This contrasted with the Roman calendar, a triumphal, linear calendar of imperial success, where the emperor was seen as the lord and savior [07:40].
  • ⚔️ Christianity was co-opted by empire. Historically, the Roman calendar superseded the Jewish cyclical time, leading Christianity to tell time as an imperial empire, exemplified by Christocracy and the Holy Roman Empire [08:51]. 🏰 Christian nationalism today is an American echo of this adoption of the Roman sense of superiority and linear time [09:35].
  • 🕊️ The central conflict is peace versus imperial power. The Christmas story is immediately followed by King Herod’s imperial infant genocide, establishing the fight between the peace of God’s kingdom and the power of empire [12:11]. 🔨 The Roman Empire, not the Jews, killed Jesus; Rome essentially killed the Messiah, but God overcame this imperial victory with the resurrection [13:12].
  • 🧘 The vision of God’s kingdom is one of equality and service. The New Testament’s description of Jesus as King is one of ultimate servanthood, where he kneels to wash his friends’ feet, defying earthly power structures [17:11]. 🌍 The kingdom is a place where the first will be last, rulers will be cast down, the poor lifted up, and the hungry well-fed, emphasizing equality, sharing, and generosity [18:30].
  • 🚫 Constantine’s conversion was a dangerous turning point. In the 4th century, Emperor Constantine saw Christianity as a useful tool to unify the Roman Empire and claimed that Jesus gave him the sign of the cross for a military victory, leading to the co-option of faith for blood on the battlefield [22:04]. 🩸 This created an imperial stream of Christianity that has since fought against renewal movements focused on justice and the poor [23:11].
  • 🇺🇸 Modern American evangelicalism embraced an imperial story. Early American evangelicalism began as a democratic, inclusive, and anti-imperial renewal movement, fighting against the imperial religion of the Anglicans [25:06]. 🛑 However, in recent decades, American evangelicalism fell prey to two errors: either confining the kingdom to heaven or pursuing a political crusade to bring their distorted, 4th-century version of an imperial kingdom to earth [27:32].
  • 📢 Christians must be a louder voice for justice. The contrast between the core biblical message and the imperial strain, like a Fox News contributor using the Lord’s Prayer over images of bombers, is a form of heresy or genocidal madness that has horrified many Christians [32:13]. 🤝 A growing backlash is prompting Christians to be louder, find allies, and make common cause with others striving for a world of justice, hospitality, and love [33:34].

🤔 Evaluation

  • 📚 Sources confirm historical conflict: The video’s core argument that Christianity has historically contained a tension between a faith-based, anti-imperial vision and an imperial, power-seeking one is well-supported by historical scholarship. The Cambridge History of Ancient Christianity confirms that the early Christian movement was birthed under the shadow of Rome’s empire and actively engaged and challenged Roman imperial power, particularly noting the Book of Revelation’s clear critique of Rome.
  • 👑 Constantine’s role is complex: The video focuses on Emperor Constantine’s adoption of Christianity as a moment of capitulation to power [21:17]. Historical sources, such as those detailed in Fourth Century Christianity, confirm Constantine’s use of Christianity to militarily consolidate the Roman Empire [21:45], including the consolidation of scripture and the Nicene Creed [22:55]. This event is a widely accepted pivot point toward Christendom, where the church became intertwined with state power.
  • 🇺🇸 Christian Nationalism as Imperial Echo: The critique of modern Christian nationalism as an American echo of imperial Christianity [09:35] aligns with numerous contemporary analyses. The books The Power Worshippers by Katherine Stewart and The Flag and the Cross by Philip S. Gorski and Samuel L. Perry extensively document how this movement seeks to use state power to enforce a specific, often white male supremacist, version of a Christian nation, prioritizing control and hierarchy over the biblical principles of servanthood and equality.
  • ✨ Topics to explore for better understanding:
    • Theological Evolution of Evangelicalism: Further explore the specific historical steps, figures, and organizations that led 20th-century American evangelicalism away from its democratic, anti-imperial roots and toward the political-imperial model described in the video.
    • Global Christian Movements: Compare the imperial strain to non-Western Christian traditions (e.g., in the Global South) to see how Christianity developed outside of the Roman/Western imperial lineage and how these traditions interpret the relationship between faith and political power.
    • Philosophy of Cyclical Time: Investigate non-Christian philosophical or religious traditions (e.g., Indigenous, Hindu, or Buddhist concepts of time) to better contrast the linear Roman model with the cyclical/spiral model of the Christian liturgical calendar.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

❓ Q: What is the primary difference between the Christian liturgical calendar and the common secular calendar?

💡 A: The primary difference is the structure of time and the narrative it tells. 📅 The secular calendar, inherited mostly from the Roman Empire, is linear, moving from beginning to middle to end, emphasizing imperial success and triumphal narratives [07:40]. 🔄 The Christian liturgical calendar is a cyclical or spiral structure of sacred stories, with the central event (Easter/Resurrection) in the middle, creating a pulsating sense of time that focuses on themes of love, hospitality, justice, and the renewal of community [04:06].

❓ Q: How does Christian nationalism today reflect historical imperial Christianity?

👑 A: Christian nationalism is a modern echo of historical imperial Christianity that began in the 4th century with the Roman Emperor Constantine [09:35]. 🏛️ This strain of Christianity prioritizes seizing earthly power and establishing a hierarchical kingdom on earth through political control, which defies the biblical image of Jesus as a servant king who preached that the first would be last [17:11].

❓ Q: How was Jesus’ concept of the Kingdom of God fundamentally different from an earthly empire?

🕊️ A: Jesus’ concept of the Kingdom of God was a no-kings movement that defied the picture of earthly kings [16:48]. 🧎 While earthly empires are built on hierarchical power, wealth, and privilege, Jesus’ kingdom is described as a place of complete equality and servanthood, where the king washes the feet of his friends [17:48], and the central command is the love of God and the love of neighbor, especially caring for the poor, hungry, and immigrant [15:13].

📚 Book Recommendations

↔️ Similar

  • 👥✝️ A People’s History of Christianity: The Other Side of the Story by Diana Butler Bass. 🌎 This book similarly explores the tension between Christianity’s imperial, power-seeking side and the subversive, social-ethic tradition that has always existed within the faith.
  • 🙌 Grounded: Finding God in the World—A Spiritual Revolution by Diana Butler Bass. 🌳 It discusses moving beyond traditional church structures to find a spiritual revolution in the world, connecting with the idea of a faith focused on communal life and the care of neighbors.
  • ✝️ God and Empire: Jesus Against Rome, Then and Now by John Dominic Crossan. ⚔️ This work analyzes how the gospels present a clear, nonviolent alternative to Roman imperial rule, providing detailed historical context for the video’s discussion of Rome’s conflict with Jesus.

🆚 Contrasting

  • ⛪ The Case for Christian Nationalism by Stephen Wolfe. 🛡️ This book presents the direct counter-argument, explicitly advocating for Christian nationalism as the necessary form of government to love our neighbors and our country, contrasting sharply with the video’s anti-imperial stance.
  • 🇺🇸 Taking Back America For God: Christian Nationalism In The United States by Andrew L. Whitehead and Samuel L. Perry. 📊 This sociological analysis documents the rise and current goals of Christian nationalism, explaining the movement’s ideology and how it is actively pursuing the imperial-style political power the video critiques.
  • 📰❓✝️ The Case for Christ: A Journalist’s Personal Investigation of the Evidence for Jesus by Lee Strobel. 🙏 This book is representative of a conservative evangelical approach that focuses intensely on apologetics and the factual certainty of doctrine, which contrasts with the progressive Christian emphasis on justice, mystery, and an evolving faith.

🎨 Creatively Related

  • ⏱️ About Time: Narrative, Fiction and the Philosophy of Time by Mark Currie. 📜 This book explores the philosophy of time, particularly how narrative shapes our understanding of the past, present, and future, relating to the video’s opening discussion on linear versus cyclical time.
  • 🪢🌾 Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants by Robin Wall Kimmerer. 🌍 This book offers a non-Western perspective on relationships, time, and community, contrasting the imperial mindset by centering on ecological gratitude and the ethics of reciprocity, similar to the biblical vision of shalom.
  • 👑 The Making of Biblical Womanhood: How the Subjugation of Women Became Gospel Truth by Beth Allison Barr. 💡 This work examines how historical power structures and interpretations have been used to enforce hierarchy and patriarchy within Christianity, an example of the imperial strain’s influence on social issues within the church.

🐦 Tweet

Graph View

Backlinks